When it comes to eye shadow, gray often plays second fiddle to black or even taupe. Open your mind to a soft dove gray and you’ll find it can look unexpectedly dramatic—and it generally flatters all skin tones. A wispy, sheer hue adds depth without all the darkness. Without eyeliner, a bit swept in the crease or on the lid appears tastefully undone. How to pull together this look? Break out the baby pink lipstick and dabble in the new crop of colored mascaras (think plum or royal blue).